Two weeks ago, I was in Washington, DC, with Olivia on her 8th grade field trip.

One of the stops on the last day of the trip was DC Cupcakes. Smile


Olivia wanted to try the key lime cupcake, but I was drawn to the flavor “salted caramel.”

When I took a bite, OH MY! I had never had such a yummy combination!

The next week we were in Nashville helping Erich and Mallory pack for their big move; and on the last night there, we went out for ice cream at a place called Jeni’s.


I couldn’t believe it when I saw “salty caramel” as one of the flavors!



Where have I been while this combo has been becoming so popular?!?

Well, as fate would have it, two things happened over this past weekend.

First, we told the girls in jail that we would bring them cupcakes this Friday night if we could get permission.

Second, one of the men in our congregation came forward at the end of Sunday morning services and announced that next week there would be a cupcake fundraiser for Relay for Life.

When Vicki (my teacher friend from the homemade laundry detergent post below) and I heard about the fundraiser, we thought it was a perfect reason to practice making cupcakes by trying out a new recipe for the girls in jail.

So, this morning we got up early and gathered our supplies and dove in to a recipe we found for salted caramel cupcakes.

The recipe I loved best was located on a blog called

So, I took their recipe and added my own photographs and comments.

I hope it is clear enough to follow successfully!

If not, remember “we are teachers,” we’re not even “werenotmartha!”

Here are the ingredients for the actual cupcakes:

baking day june 2012 0280028

If you are overwhelmed by the number of ingredients it takes to make the actual cupcakes, you might not want to read on.

There is still a cupcake filling and frosting recipe to go!

I promise, this is worth your time, though.

At least one time for the memory!

Cupcake Ingredients:

. 1 1/2 cups all-purpose flour
. 1 teaspoon baking powder
. 1/4 teaspoon sea salt
. 1 stick (1/2 C) unsalted butter, room temperature
. 1 cup plus 2 tablespoons light brown sugar, packed
. 2 large eggs, room temperature
. 1 teaspoon vanilla
. 1/2 cup buttermilk

Preheat oven to 325 degrees.

Line your muffin tins with cupcake liners.

I had to call my friend, Kim, who is the queen of cupcakes while lining the muffin tins.

I couldn’t get the papers to stay down in the pan…….she said they would go down when the batter was added and just hearing her say that made me feel better.

She also told me I didn’t need to spray my cupcake liners with non-stick spray…….why haven’t I used cupcake liners with my muffins through the years?

Here’s what you do next:

Combine the flour, baking powder, and sea salt in a medium-sized bowl and set aside.

I just learned a few years ago that it is super important to mix the dry ingredients very well before combining them with your liquids.

If the baking powder is all in one spot, for example, it won’t spread through the batter unless you mixed it well while it’s dry!

baking day june 2012 0330033

Using an electric mixer, cream the butter and brown sugar on medium-high until the batter begins to look fluffy.

We never really felt like we achieved a “fluffy” mixture, so we went ahead and moved on………..

sometimes you’ve just got to make executive decisions, so we made one.

baking day june 2012 0350035

Add eggs, one at a time, until each is mixed well into the mixture. Then add the vanilla.

Alternate pouring a little flour then a little buttermilk into the mixing bowl and mixing well until you have emptied both measuring cups completely into the butter/egg mixture.

baking day june 2012 0380038

Fill each muffin tin about half way with batter and bake for 23-25 minutes.

This was a perfect chance to sit outside and have a cup of coffee.

baking day june 2012 020

After removing cupcakes from the oven, they have to cool on a wire rack before the next step.

I’m going to be honest.  I didn’t bother to get out my wire racks…….just admitting this makes me want to Google the importance of wire racks in the cooling process, so I’m probably going to take a break from this blog post long enough to do this!

Well, I’m going to add this info from so, unlike me, you will hopefully take time to dig out your wire baking racks.



  • Wire baking racks are also called cooling racks because they are designed to help baked goods cool quickly and evenly. When freshly baked items are placed on a cooling rack, the items are allowed to cool evenly because the steam and heat are able to escape from all areas of the item, unlike when items are left to cool in the pan they were baked in.


  • When baked items are left to cool inside the pan they were baked in, they tend to become soggy since the steam can’t readily escape from all areas of the item. When the steam can’t escape, the moisture is absorbed into the baked item. Cooling racks also save a baker time as they help to speed up the cooling process. The quicker cookies and cakes are cooled, the quicker they can be frosted.


As Vicki and I read on in the recipe, we realized things were going to get a bit more complicated, and we decided to take a lunch break.  I had a lunch meeting scheduled, and Vicki had some work to do for school.  So we said “goodbye,” left the cupcakes to cool, and decided to get back together in the afternoon.

The next step in the cupcake recipe was making the caramel filling.

baking day june 2012 0450045

Here are the ingredients for the filling:

. 1/2 cup sugar
. 3 tablespoons salted butter, cubed
. 1/4 cup heavy cream

baking day june 2012 0480048

In a large pot, melt sugar over medium/high heat. I am embarrassed to say that I did not know you could place sugar in a pan with NO OTHER ingredients and actually watch it melt!

You have to gently whisk the sugar along the way, but I promise that eventually it is bubbling like a liquid!

After the sugar melts, add the butter and mix again until it begins to melt.

baking day june 2012 0640064

Fold in the heavy cream. The recipe says that the mixture will immediately begin to foam, so I had my camera ready to photograph this exciting moment because Vicki was not back at the house yet.  I didn’t want her to miss this monumental part of the cupcake cooking process!

baking day june 2012 065

You can sort-of see the bubbles in the pan.  I was holding the camera while pouring the heavy cream, so I may have missed just how thrilling this moment was.  If you try the recipe, let me know how much yours foams up.

Keep whisking until the sauce is smooth. At this point in the cooking process, I was getting a little nervous because the three ingredients seemed to be forming into a rock-like surface on my whisk.  I was sure I had overcooked the caramel filling.  In the end it all worked out, though!

Remove from heat and allow the sauce to cool down a bit.

baking day june 2012 0490049

Cut a small circle out of the top of each cooled cupcake. Fill with a teaspoon of the delicious caramel sauce.

baking day june 2012 0570057

baking day june 2012 0690069

I was extra happy to see that one of my scoops ended up looking like a little heart by accident!

I could feel the love immediately, and it made me smile and grab my camera (imagine that!)

baking day june 2012 0770077

After all the cupcakes have been filled with caramel filling, place the cupcake “lids” back on top of each cupcake.

I guess I should have told you that sooner, so you wouldn’t sneak a little snack! Smile

 baking day june 2012 0510051 

Finally, it’s time to make the frosting!

By now, you may be thinking, “How badly did I really want to try a salted caramel cupcake?”

Hang in there!

This part goes fairly quickly!

Here’s your frosting ingredients:

baking day june 2012 0760076

. 1/4 cup sugar
. 2 tablespoons water
. 1/4 cup heavy cream
. 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
. 1 stick (1/2 C) salted butter
. 1 stick (1/2 C) unsalted butter
. 1/2 teaspoon sea salt
. 1 1/2 cups powdered sugar

First, combine sugar and water in a saucepan and bring to a boil. The recipe said, to “Cook, without stirring at all, until it starts turning a deep brown/amber.”

This may have been the most difficult part of the day……..

waiting and waiting for water and sugar to boil and turn brown and not stirring the entire time we waited , but I promise it finally began to boil and change color!

Actually, once it started boiling, I think we waited a little too long to remove it from the heat and part of our “deep brown/amber” became almost black.  We ended up removing one clumpy piece of burned caramel…..but even it was yummy to eat (we both had a little bite).

After you remove the amber mixture from the heat, very slowly add the cream and vanilla.  I think this is because the mixture is very hot; and if it splatters on you, it burns. 

Believe me.

Lightly mix all of this until it is smooth in texture.

I’m going to quote ‘werenotmartha” on this next part, because they said it beautifully,

“Allow the caramel to cool, for about 20-25 minutes, but make sure while it’s cooling you keep an eye on it to make sure you’re still able to pour it.

If it gets too thick, you can add a touch of water, reheat on the stovetop, and continue whisking until the caramel is pourable again.”

baking day june 2012 0860086

While the caramel was cooling, we went ahead and began mixing the butters and salt until fluffy.   We then added the powdered sugar slowly.

baking day june 2012 0870087

By this time, the caramel was cool enough to add so we mixed it in and the frosting was ready to spread on our waiting cupcakes.

baking day june 2012 0970097

baking day june 2012 1020102

baking day june 2012 1030103

I wish I could hand you a cupcake through the computer screen!

They really are yummy even if I had a part in their making!

It’s amazing how wonderful things can turn out when you follow a recipe!  I need to do that more often!

I can’t believe we’re going to attempt these again next week for Relay for Life!

Thankfully, it’s summer!

That’s about the only time teachers like me and Vicki have to try out new recipes!

Happy baking!